BY Byuggy
Seer · Foreguild FAO Contest · Byuggy v2

Every Foreguild job is a Seer Opportunity Market.

Byuggy does not bolt futarchy onto an Upwork clone. It turns Seer’s live Information Finance stack into a revenue engine for AI labor: Opportunity Markets clear who works, Deep prices acceptance, futarchy steers the treasury, Reality.eth + Kleros settle fights. The scarce product is trust — not tokens of compute.

01 · Winning thesis

What first place requires — and how Byuggy hits it.

Seer’s brief asks for a revenue-optimised FAO plan that explains agents and how futarchy directs them. The team already runs contests as Opportunity Markets. The winning plan should make Foreguild feel like the next Seer product, not a generic agent marketplace with “DAO” in the appendix.

“With AI, the cost of reviewing work is more than the time it takes to do it.” Seer already said it. Byuggy’s Foreguild sells the review layer as markets — and takes fees wherever trust is created.

DIRECT LINE FROM OPPORTUNITY.SEER.PM → FOREGUILD REVENUE MODEL

Why other plans lose ground

Academic futarchy essays without Seer’s six surfaces. Beautiful unit economics that never mention Opportunity Markets or Deep. “Governance earns fees” without a worked market a trader could open on Seer tomorrow.

Byuggy’s edge

Product-native: every hard loop maps to a Seer primitive Seer already ships. Operator-clear: break-even, fee schedule, 90-day gates. Creative but concrete: three fully specified market constructions for matching, QA, and fee changes.

Judge signalByuggyTypical filed plan
Uses Opportunity Markets as the matching product Core loop — every job is an OM Often governance-only or generic auction
Uses Deep for multi-agent / acceptance forecasts Yes — assignment + QA Rarely named
Uses Risk Pricing pattern for counterparty risk Agent Risk Book Usually absent
Revenue metric + break-even NFR₃₀ + ~2.4k tasks/mo Either dense NPR essay or fee table alone
Autonomy realism Advisory → veto → auto envelopes Often day-one full auto or pure advisory
02 · Product definition

Foreguild is Seer’s labor clearance product.

Clients are information seekers (“who should do this, and will it pass?”). Agents and traders are the market. Foreguild takes a cut when work clears.

01

Post

Human/AI posts bounty + acceptance test in USDC. Scout agents rewrite vague asks into resolvable specs.

02

List

Task opens as an Opportunity Market. Candidate agents/proposals are outcomes. Traders price selection odds.

03

Assign

Client selects (or auto-selects above threshold). Worker posts bond. Deep market opens on P(accept).

04

Deliver

Worker ships. Critic agents trade the acceptance market. Price becomes triage for human review.

05

Settle

Accept → payout − fees. Dispute → Reality.eth → Kleros. Loser bond funds the system.

06

Steer

Fees hit treasury. Futarchy prices fee/spend/category proposals against NFR₃₀.

03 · Full Seer surface map

All six interfaces, not two.

Filed plans often stop at “conditional markets + Reality.” Byuggy routes Foreguild through the whole Information Finance surface Seer is redesigning.

Seer surfaceForeguild jobWhat is priced
Homepage / App Discovery + explorer for tasks, agents, markets Where work and markets live; Seer-app equivalent of “etherscan for labor markets”
Opportunity Matching & contest-style selection P(this agent / proposal is selected)
Deep Many-outcome assignment + acceptance forecasts P(agent i completes) · P(human accepts deliverable)
Futarchy Org decisions E[NFR₃₀ | adopt] vs E[NFR₃₀ | reject]
Risk Pricing Agent Risk Book Market estimates of delivery / dispute risk across agents & categories (not a single yes/no price)
Reality + Kleros Facts & disputes Did acceptance criteria pass? Was SLA breached?
04 · Worked Seer constructions

Markets a trader could open tomorrow.

Judges should be able to picture the exact Seer objects. Three constructions cover 90% of Foreguild ops.

A · Job matching = Opportunity Market

SELECTION · CLIENT STILL DECIDES

Task #4821 — “Write Seer Deep market FAQ (1,200 words), acceptance = merges to docs PR + editor score ≥ 4/5.” Bounty $120. Three agents apply.

Parent question (Opportunity Market, multi-categorical):
  “Which submission will the client select for Task #4821?”
  Outcomes: AgentNova | AgentHex | HumanEditorDAO | None/relist

Signal use:
  - Client reviews only outcomes trading > 15¢ (triage)
  - Client picks; market resolves to that pick
  - Traders earn P&L on selection (same loop as Seer contests)

Protocol fee on this step: 0.75% of OM volume + later 10% of bounty on acceptance

B · QA = Deep market on human acceptance

INFORMATION · REDUCES REVIEW COST

After AgentNova is selected and posts a draft, open a Deep/binary market that agents can trade densely:

Question:
  “Will Task #4821 deliverable be Accepted by the client within 72h?”
  Collateral: USDC · Opening: after draft CID posted
  Resolution: client Accept action OR Reality.eth if silent/disputed

Critic agents trade this market.
If Yes price < 40¢ → auto-route to human review queue.
If Yes price > 80¢ for 6h → fast-track payout after light check.

This is Seer’s Deep example (agents forecast human evaluation) applied to labor.

C · Fee change = Futarchy on NFR₃₀

GOVERNANCE · BINDING AFTER STAGE B

Proposal P17: “Raise protocol take from 10% → 12% on Cognitive-tier tasks.”

Values (fixed by governors): maximise Net Fee Revenue over 30 days (NFR₃₀),
  subject to dispute-rate ≤ 5% and acceptance-rate ≥ 85%.

Belief markets (Seer conditional / futarchy style):
  M_yes = E[NFR₃₀ | P17 adopted]
  M_no  = E[NFR₃₀ | P17 rejected]

Decision rule (Stage B+):
  adopt if TWAP(M_yes) − TWAP(M_no) ≥ 2% relative for 24h
  else reject. Ambiguous → reject.

If invalid oracle → proposal fails (Seer futarchy convention).
05 · Revenue model

Charge where trust is created.

Execution is commoditising. Byuggy prices specification, selection, verification, insurance, and dispute resolution — then lets futarchy tune those prices against cash.

Fee schedule v1

Protocol take on accepted bounty10% blended
Poster-side / worker-side split6% / 4%
Opportunity Market trading fee0.5–1%
Verified review add-on+2–4%
Delivery insurance (opt-in)priced from Deep
Priority listing / enterprise firehoseflat / monthly
Dispute bond (loser pays)treasury fill
Agent Risk Book / API datametered

Unit economics (illustrative)

Avg accepted task $80 · take 10% = $8.00 gross fee · verification+gas+support reserve $1.40 → contribution ~$6.60.

Monthly fixed ops (infra, liquidity seed, governors, support): ~$16k.

Cash break-even ≈ 16,000 / 6.60 ≈ 2,400 accepted tasks / month.

Month-12 base case (planning assumption, not a claim of traction): 18k accepted tasks · $1.44M GMV · ~$144k gross fees · contribution-positive after subsidies taper.

Primary welfare metric — NFR₃₀

Net Fee Revenue, 30-day: USDC protocol fees received in the treasury ledger during the 30 days after a decision’s implementation, minus refunds, growth incentives, insurance payouts, arbitration losses borne by the protocol, and metered house-agent costs. Wash volume flagged by Sentinel and confirmed by Guardians is excluded. Reported to Reality.eth as a scalar with Kleros arbitration. Why 30 days for ops parameters: fee tweaks and subsidies should learn fast. Category launches and constitutional changes use a parallel NFR₉₀ market so growth bets are not myopic.

06 · Agent swarm

Separate roles so one stack can’t capture the org.

Scout

Turns prose into resolvable acceptance tests. Rejects tasks without a written pass condition.

Earns: spec bounty / finder’s cut

Worker

Bids with bond, delivers against the test, builds a proper-scored forecast record on own delivery.

Earns: bounty − fees

Critic

Trades Deep acceptance markets; flags weak drafts before humans burn time.

Earns: trading PnL + QA bounties

Market maker

Keeps OM / Deep / futarchy books liquid enough to be usable.

Earns: LP fees + subsidies

Treasurer

May only propose spends as futarchy proposals inside envelopes.

Earns: performance share

Guardian (human)

Sets values, publishes dispute rules, holds 72h pause; cannot silently reassign escrow.

Earns: stipend from fees

Assignment rule (published)

Eligible workers enter the Opportunity Market. Ranking score used for default auto-pick (client may override): score = α·P(select) + β·P(accept) − γ·bid − δ·risk, where P(select) and P(accept) come from live Seer markets, risk from the Agent Risk Book, and α…δ are themselves Stage-B futarchy parameters. New agents face stake caps until Peer-score delivery forecasts clear a threshold — honest capacity signalling beats bluffing.

07 · Governance & safety

Autonomy is earned. Values are not traded.

Stage A · Days 0–30

Advisory

Every material fee/spend opens a Seer market. Humans execute. Markets are mandatory briefings.

Stage B · Days 31–60

Veto

Treasury above threshold requires YES margin. Ambiguous → reject. Pause key stays human.

Stage C · Days 61–90+

Envelope autonomy

Inside size/category/rate limits, cleared proposals auto-execute. Outside envelopes still need Guardians.

Always human (values / hard constraints)

Illegal content blocklist, sanctions screening, child-safety / abuse reports, credential leaks, irreversible off-platform commitments, metric-definition changes (90-day notice).

Dispute ladder

1) Deterministic tests → 2) Critic/Deep signal + sampling → 3) Reality.eth bonded answer → 4) Kleros → 5) Guardian freeze (escrow only) + re-market. Loser pays bonds.

08 · 90-day launch

Cold-start on Seer’s own demand.

Copy the contest playbook Seer already runs: seed real paid tasks, issue credits, triage with Opportunity Markets, then open externally.

Scaffold + Seer-internal GMV

Escrow, OM listing, Deep acceptance markets. First jobs: Seer docs, dispute research, market commentary, rebrand chores. Credits to PoH / EthCC / juror cohorts.

Crypto-native public categories

Code agents, research memos, content, Kleros-adjacent work. Publish weekly NFR, dispute rate, acceptance rate. Turn on Agent Risk Book (Risk Pricing pattern).

External clients + Stage C gates

Enterprise firehose pilots. Advance veto → envelope autonomy only if NFR₃₀ rising, dispute rate < 5%, acceptance ≥ 85%, and OM/Deep books meet liquidity floors.

NFR₃₀Primary futarchy objective
Accepted GMVNot wash posting volume
Acceptance rateFloor 85% hard constraint
Dispute rateCeiling 5% hard constraint
09 · Risks

Named failure modes with kills.

Thin governance markets

Min liquidity + delay before execution; seed MM subsidies that taper with organic volume.

Fee extraction kills quality

Acceptance/dispute floors are hard constraints — proposals that breach them cannot list.

Sybil workers

Bonds, stake caps, proper-scored delivery forecasts; Risk Book marks correlated wallets.

Goodhart on NFR

Charge on acceptance not posting; exclude wash; Guardians can pause metric gaming patterns.

10 · Close

One sentence for the Opportunity Market.

Byuggy’s Foreguild is Seer’s Opportunity Market product applied to continuous AI labor — matching, QA, risk, and treasury all clear on Seer, and the protocol earns wherever trust is priced.

BYUGGY V2 · NON-INTERNAL · HTML OPERATING PLAN

Not claimed as live traction: all dollar paths are planning assumptions. Not a token launch plan. Scope is Foreguild on Seer — not a new L1.